On a stormy evening in November 1953, a mystery unfolded over Lake Superior that continues to baffle historians and aviation enthusiasts alike. It began when an unexpected object appeared on the radar of a United States Air Force (USAF) facility. This prompted officials to dispatch two airmen to investigate. What transpired next remains one of the most enduring enigmas of aviation history.

The Radar Detection

The story started on November 23, 1953, at an Air Defense Command facility located on the U.S.-Canada border. Reports of the weather vary, with some accounts describing snowfall while others mention a stormy atmosphere. At approximately 6 p.m., an operator detected an anomaly on the radar—an unknown entity moving through restricted airspace near the Soo Locks. This is an area crucial for shipping on Lake Superior. No American or Canadian aircraft were authorized to be in the vicinity, raising alarms.

In response, officials scrambled a F-89 Scorpion jet, which had been temporarily stationed at Kinross Air Force Base, about 20 miles from the Soo Locks. The aircraft was originally based at Truax Air Force Base in Madison, Wisconsin, roughly 400 miles away. Unfortunately, it would never return to its original home.

The Airmen and Their Pursuit

First Lieutenant Felix Moncla, an experienced pilot with over 800 hours of flying time, took the controls of the F-89. Assisting as the radar operator was Second Lieutenant Robert Wilson. Moncla, who had initially aimed for a career in medicine, had switched paths to join the Air Force three years prior. The two men set off into the stormy skies, determined to uncover the identity of the mysterious object.

As they approached the radar blip, Wilson struggled to keep track of the unidentified craft. The UFO appeared to move erratically across the radar screen. The pursuit turned into a high-altitude game of cat and mouse. Much to everyone’s surprise the object descending from 25,000 feet to just 7,000 feet. As the two airmen continued their chase, they finally began to gain ground on the anomaly.

The Disappearance

Approximately 70 miles off the Keweenaw Peninsula, Moncla and Wilson’s F-89 caught up with the unknown object after tracking it for about 160 miles. However, what happened next is shrouded in mystery. According to witness accounts, the two blips on the radar screen appeared to merge into one. Local media, including The Capital Times, reported that the Truax jet was followed on the radar until its image fused with that of the object it was pursuing.

In an instant, Moncla and Wilson’s jet seemingly vanished from radar, leaving officials stunned. An official report later indicated that the F-89’s radar signal disappeared without a trace. To compound the mystery, the unknown craft’s blip also veered off course and subsequently vanished.

The Search Efforts

In the aftermath of this perplexing incident, the U.S. military launched an extensive search-and-rescue operation. Aircraft and boats scoured the area over Lake Superior, but despite their efforts, no sign of Moncla, Wilson, or their F-89 was ever discovered. The experienced airmen and their jet had vanished into thin air, leaving behind a mystery that remains unresolved.

What Happened?

The disappearance of First Lieutenant Felix Moncla and Second Lieutenant Robert Wilson continues to perplex investigators and enthusiasts of aviation lore. Numerous theories have been proposed, ranging from UFO encounters to tragic accidents. However, despite extensive searches and investigations, the truth behind their disappearance remains elusive.

This chilling incident not only highlights the mysterious nature of the skies over Lake Superior but also serves as a reminder of the risks faced by those who serve in the military. As we ponder the fate of these two brave airmen, the question remains: what truly happened on that stormy night in November 1953?

Learn more about the rich history of the Eastern Upper Peninsula, Central Upper Peninsula, or Western Upper Peninsula.